In accordance with the Council’s Notice on Discussions and Fly-sheets (Statutes and Ordinances, 2025, p. 118), the five fly‑sheets received for the ballots on senior administrative offices (Graces 2 and 3 of 29 July 2026) are reprinted below. The fly-sheets are reprinted in the order in which they appeared in the ballot booklet, which was random. For the result of the ballots see p. 98 (1) and p. 98 (2).
We wish to express our support for the changes proposed to the Senior Administrative Offices, as described in the Council’s Report.1
The creation of a Chief Operating Officer role is an important step towards improving the coordination, alignment and operational delivery across our Professional Service functions. This role is more appropriate for the modern support environment and, because of parallel restructuring of other senior administrative posts, its creation is not expected to result in increased expenditure on senior Professional Services leadership overall. Appointing a COO has been a recommendation of the Board of Scrutiny for several years and has strong support from Heads of School and Directors of Professional Service teams.
Professional Services is a complex group of enabling services which represents around 2,000 staff in the University Administration Services (UAS) and University Information Services (UIS). These services include Planning and Investment, Academic Planning and Policy, Academic Operations, Governance and Compliance, Legal Services, Estates, Finance, Health and Safety, Human Resources, Information Services Change Management, Data and Insights, and Change Management.
The effectiveness and efficiency of these services have a material impact on the day-to-day delivery of the University’s research, teaching and operational activities and on the experience of staff and students. The landscape in which we operate has evolved considerably over the last 10 years and we must evolve with that landscape. The proposed changes to the senior administrative offices and the transfer of UIS to become part of the UAS will strengthen leadership and coordination across the service areas, moving the University towards a more contemporary model of professional services leadership and delivery.
The anticipated benefits of creating the Chief Operating Officer role and reorganisation of the relationship between UIS and UAS are:
•Improved operational coordination and effectiveness between functions
•Improved strategic, business and financial planning
•Improved alignment, communication and coordination between UAS Directors
•Ability to prioritise resources across functions to address service needs
•Enhanced focus on Professional Service redesign
•Closer alignment of IT and digital support to improve our professional service provision while also maintaining its focus on supporting academic needs.
•Enhanced provision of staff development in an evolving digital environment.
Currently, all the Directors of UAS Divisions are line-managed by the Registrary, requiring the person in that role to have strong governance and compliance skills as well as experience of operational management of finance, estates and human resources. However, since this arrangement was put in place many years ago, the University has grown substantially in size and complexity and also in regulatory burden, so one person no longer has the capacity to perform all these tasks effectively.
These changes are necessary to help the University address current academic and operational challenges. Please vote in favour of both Grace 2 and Grace 3.
Signed by the following 42 members of the Regent House:
G. Ahmadi-Assalemi
K.-A. Allen
J. A. D. Aston
G. A. Bagley
K. Baig
D. D. Benham
M. G. Brian
B. J. Brown
P. J. Calleja
S. T. Carpenter
S. R. Clarke
S. E. d’Ambrumenil
J. S. Dennis
A. Downie
C. J. Edmonds
A. J. D. Flett
J. P. Gardner
M. R. W. Glover
A. L. Greer
K. N. Hageman
R. L. Hey
D. R. Hill
J. Holgate
K. Livingstone
A. Martin Campillo
G. V. Matthews
R. M. Mortier
K. A. Munir
A. D. Neely
A. Nitch-Smith
A. L. Odgers
A. Philpott
C. J. Russell
J. S. Simons
J. L. Thorogood
A. E. Traub
B. Vira
M. Wallberg
B. A. Warn
A. Wathey
G. N. Wells
J. M. Wyburd
We strongly support Graces 2 and 3 as amended by the Notice of 23 July 2026 and submitted for approval on 29 July 2026 (Reporter, 6835, 2025–26, p. 681). We urge you to vote placet, in favour of both Graces.
The purpose of these Graces is two-fold. First, to establish the Office of Chief Operating Officer (COO) sitting alongside the Registrary and the Academic Secretary at the head of the University’s administration. Second, to make the University Information Services (UIS) into an Information Services Division within the Unified Administrative Service (UAS) with a Director reporting to the COO rather than to the Vice-Chancellor (VC) as at present.
We believe that these changes are both necessary and urgent. Recent Allocations Reports (e.g. Reporter, 6787, 2024–25, p. 610) have illustrated the disproportionate increase in Administrative Staff over the last decade. The University self‑evidently needs to strengthen the control and integration of its administrative operations and to align them better with its core academic mission. This led the Board of Scrutiny in its 29th Annual Report (Reporter, 6756, 2024–25, p. 65) to urge consideration of the appointment of a COO.
We agree with the Council that the office of Registrary has had a broad and, at times, unmanageable set of responsibilities requiring a set of skills seldom found in one individual. We agree that there is a need to separate the roles of University Secretary and the Head of the UAS. We believe that a COO is needed for coordination of UAS/UIS resources and activity, in order to deliver more cost-effective and efficient professional services.
Furthermore, the appointment of a COO is urgently required because the Registrary role has been vacant since December 2025, resulting in the current Chief Financial Officer (CFO) deferring his retirement, other colleagues having to provide temporary cover, and knock-on effects on recruitment to other vacant posts. This is not a sustainable position for the University, particularly given the complex demands recent high-profile events are placing on our senior officers.
In the long term we favour the appointment of a COO rather than another CFO. The University’s mission is enabled by its finances, not undertaken in pursuit of money. We argue that, unlike a CFO, a COO will have the remit and the authority to ensure that the University’s administration delivers in pursuit of that mission. Finally, the proposal to make the COO part of a triumvirate alongside the Registrary (henceforth essentially the University Secretary) and Academic Secretary was a decision the Council took in response to extensive feedback, including Discussion remarks, from members of the Regent House. We commend the Council for listening.
The proposal for the UIS to become another Division within the UAS flows from that reasoning, supported by the evolution of our computing needs. The UIS was formed by the merger of the University Computing Service with the Management Information Services Division. The University Computing Service started in 1961 as a ‘spin off’ of the former Computer Laboratory when the novelty of computing made it an academic endeavour. In the present-day, computing and networking technologies are a keystone of all of the University’s activity, with most users’ requirements met by ‘off the shelf’ systems and software. Making the University’s administration operate effectively and efficiently will require a coherent approach to the use of technology across both the University administration and the academic University. The COO needs to be in a position to ensure that this happens. Having the Director of UIS report to the VC breaks that coherency.
We recognise that the UIS needs to better support the academic University alongside the University’s administration as there are specific requirements of ‘scholarly computing’ that are distinct from more mundane, commodity uses of computers. But, as with the other professional services, we believe this aim is best served by having a single Information Services Division operating effectively as part of a UAS, under the leadership of someone (the COO) who will be held to account for ensuring that the academic University is effectively and efficiently supported in ‘contributing to society through education, learning and research at the highest international levels of excellence’.
Signed by the following 120 members of the Regent House:
G. P. Allen
A. T. Archibald
J. A. D. Aston
G. A. Bagley
N. Bampos
P. D. Barker
A. C. Bayley
J. R. Bellingham
D. D. Benham
N. G. Berloff
R. J. Bowring
H. Bradford
M. G. Brian
R. Bujdoso
M. E. Cates
C. P. Caulfield
A. A. Copestake
S. J. Cowley
J. A. Crowcroft
M. S. Davies Wykes
A. C. Davis
N. Dorey
R. V. L. Doubleday
J. H. Durrell
C. J. Edmonds
J. G. Evans
R. C. Evans
S. L. D. Falk
D. J. Field
S. C. Franklin
J. L. Gibson
G. F. Gilmore
L. F. Gladden
M. R. W. Glover
D. J. Goode
A. L. Greer
B. Groisman
T. C. Grosser
A. N. Halliday
P. H. Haynes
D. R. Hewitt
R. L. Hey
D. W. Holton
D. R. Howarth
P. M. R. Howell
I. J. Humphrey
M. Ivan
A. S. Jeffrey
G. Johnson
D. R. H. Jones
T. M. Jones
E. M. A. Kammerer
F. E. Karet
J. H. Keeler
R. R. Kerswell
M. A. Kleppmann
M. Kudlinska
I. M. Leslie
K. Livingstone
S. J. Lucy
S. G. McDonald
S. A. McTavish
A. V. S. Madhavapeddy
S. H. Mandelbrote
R. K. Mantiuk
J. M. R. Matheson
G. V. Matthews
D. J. Maxwell
W. I. Milne
A. C. Minson
R. M. Mortier
K. A. Munir
A. Mycroft
A. D. Neely
A. L. Odgers
S. M. Oosthuizen
K. Ottewell
M. J. C. Parker Dixon
M. Parsons
T. J. Pedley
A. W. A. Peterson
J. Phillips
A. Philpott
J. Plummer Braeckman
M. R. E. Proctor
A. V. Protasio Palomino
C. M. F. Rae
O. Rath-Spivack
G. A. Reid
D. M. Reiner
D. J. Reynolds
P. J. Rogerson
C. Russell
N. A. Rutter
P. A. V. Sarris
T. M. Sauerwald
C. Schran
A. N. Scott
D. S. Secher
J. S. Simons
H. Smith
J. Spence
K. E. Spence
D. M. Thompson
M. J. Tilby
C. A. Tout
A. E. Traub
P. J. van Houten
B. Vira
M. Wallberg
C. D. Warner
A. Wathey
G. N. Wells
N. J. White
T. L. Williams
H. J. R. Wilton
D. J. Wischik
J. Wolf
J. L. N. Wood
M. R. Wormald
We write collectively as Heads of School, Deputy Heads of School and Heads of Institution to express our strong support for the Council’s proposal to establish the office of Chief Operating Officer (COO) and to redistribute responsibilities across the senior administrative leadership in a clearer, more sustainable, and more academically aligned structure (Council Report1).
The proposal was subject to wide consultation open to all staff, and the Council, in its Report, responded directly to concerns raised, producing a revised proposal that reflects the realities of leading large, complex academic institutions such as Cambridge.2
The current concentration of operational oversight within the Registrary’s remit has become increasingly difficult to reconcile with the scale and diversity [of] the University’s professional support services in UAS. The revised model – three main roles (Registrary, Academic Secretary, COO), each with coherent portfolios and clear lines of accountability – provides a more workable and future proof framework to support the academic priorities of the University.
From the perspective of the Schools and their constituent Departments, the benefits are threefold:
1.Improved coordination of support services. Bringing operational divisions together under a COO offers the prospect of a clearer strategic direction, improved service delivery and better integration across administrative domains. This is essential for supporting education and research at scale across the academic University. It should also support more effective prioritisation of institutional initiatives and workload demands on Schools and Departments, helping to ensure that requests from the University’s administrative services are better coordinated and aligned with academic priorities.
2.Better alignment between academic and administrative leadership. The Academic Secretary’s role is strengthened and clarified, ensuring that academic governance and academic support functions remain firmly connected to the General Board and the University’s mission.
3.More manageable and sustainable senior roles. The Registrary’s governance focused responsibilities are preserved and appropriately distinguished from operational management. This separation reduces role overload and hence will enable more effective leadership.
We note that the Council has listened carefully to feedback and has refined the proposals accordingly, including clarifying delegation powers, and, crucially, ensuring that the structure supports – not supplants – the University’s academically led culture and leadership.
In our judgement, the proposed arrangements will strengthen the University’s ability to support our academic community and to deliver high quality services. They represent a thoughtful and necessary evolution of our administrative framework.
We therefore support Graces 2 and 3 and encourage members of the Regent House to do likewise.
Signed by the following 55 members of the Regent House:
K.-A. Allen
J. A. D. Aston
G. A. Bagley
D. D. Benham
M. G. Brian
M. D. Castle
J. W. Dalley
M. S. Desai
N. Dorey
C. Durkan
C. J. Edmonds
M. Edmonds
J. G. Evans
J. P. Gardner
B. J. Glover
M. R. W. Glover
A. L. Greer
K. N. Hageman
R. L. Hey
J. M. Hibberd
L. Hooper
T. M. Jones
A. Korhonen
H. Laman
R. Lawson
S. F. Lee
K. Livingstone
G. V. Matthews
E. E. Mawdsley
E. A. Miska
R. M. Mortier
A. J. Murray
A. D. Neely
J. A. Neufeld
A. L. Odgers
K. Ottewell
J. E. Page
G. T. Parks
R. V. Penty
A. Philpott
M. D. Potter
J. J. W. Robinson
S. Russell
S. J. Savory
O. C. H. Shorttle
J. S. Simons
E. S. J. Smith
G. L. Syson
A. E. Traub
D. J. Trippett
B. Vira
M. Wallberg
A. Wathey
T. T. Weil
J. M. Wyburd
2Reporter, 2025–26: 6823, p. 447; 6831, p. 581.
The University has grown considerably in the scale and sophistication of its operations, as have the regulatory and compliance requirements it must meet. The University needs a modern, fit-for-purpose professional services function that supports it, and the many people who work in it, in delivering its mission. As presently defined, the role of the Registrary is both too broad and too deep for any one person to meet all expectations.
The proposed tripartite structure will provide clear professional services support for (i) academic planning and policy, (ii) governance and regulation, and (iii) operations, and will strengthen a focus on delivery. Accountability will be clear and robust, with each responsible officer under the direction of the Council or the General Board. A strong professional services structure, including bringing University Information Services (UIS) into the Unified Administrative Service (UAS), will give staff and students more coherent and better integrated services. These proposals are the result of extensive consultation across the University and have attracted strong support.
We urge members of the Regent House to vote in favour of Grace 2, to establish the office of Chief Operating Officer and elevate the role of Academic Secretary, and in favour of Grace 3, to bring UIS into the UAS.
Signed by the following 52 members of the Regent House:
G. P. Allen
J. A. D. Aston
G. A. Bagley
J. J. Baumberg
D. D. Benham
S. Birse
M. G. Brian
D. A. Cardwell
J. M. Cullen
J. Dekkers
J. S. Dennis
J. T. Dix
J. H. Durrell
C. J. Edmonds
N. A. Fleck
A. J. Flewitt
K. J. Gardiner
H. Ge
M. R. W. Glover
A. L. Greer
K. N. Hageman
A. N. Halliday
I. J. Humphrey
J. L. Huppert
A. R. Jackson
T. M. Jones
C. F. Kaminski
S. T. Lam
F. Mancini
G. V. Matthews
T. H. W. Minshall
R. M. Mortier
D. P. J. Moulin-Stozek
K. A. Munir
A. D. Neely
A. L. Odgers
S. M. Oosthuizen
R. M. Owens
R. V. Penty
A. Philpott
M. Pierce
S. Schnall
J. S. Simons
P. M. D. Thomas-McEwen
A. E. Traub
P. J. van Houten
B. Vira
M. Wallberg
A. Wathey
G. N. Wells
P. J. Williamson
J. M. Wyburd
We urge members of the Regent House to vote non-placet on Graces 2 and 3.
There may well be a strong, reasonable case for creating a Chief Operating Officer to relieve pressure on central administration. That is not what is at issue. The problem is that the Council has taken a major operational proposal and attached to it a series of distinct, contentious constitutional changes, presenting the whole package on a take-it-or-leave-it basis.
This approach mirrors the tactic in legislative politics of attaching controversial ‘riders’ to an otherwise acceptable bill. Members are asked simultaneously to:
•Create a new office of Chief Operating Officer;
•Redefine and narrow the historic role of the Registrary;
•Elevate the Academic Secretary into a new administrative leadership triad;
•Strip University Information Services (UIS) of its independent Ordinance and absorb it into the Unified Administrative Service (UAS);
•Pass an extensive series of consequential constitutional amendments.
1. Major Constitutional Changes Require Separate Consideration
Combining these measures into two binary ballots relies on members accepting problematic governance shifts simply to secure the main operational reform they want. Proponents claim the Board of Scrutiny recommended creating a COO. In fact, the Board merely recommended a review to weigh the ‘costs and benefits’ of such a post (Reporter, 6756, 2024–25, p. 65). Overstating that recommendation to justify bundling unrelated governance changes denies the Regent House its proper scrutinising role. Creating a COO, restructuring senior officers, and absorbing previously independent bodies are distinct constitutional decisions that warrant separate justification and independent votes on their merits.
2. Dismantling Statutory Protections Sets a Dangerous Precedent
The independent Ordinance governing the UIS was established following extensive debate in the 2013 Joint Report (Reporter, 6302, 2012–13, p. 418), explicitly to ensure that academic infrastructure and research computing were not subsumed into generic administrative management. Treating the repeal of this Ordinance as a mere afterthought to an operational restructure ignores that deliberate constitutional settlement. If specialised academic support functions can be folded into central corporate management simply because they are deemed ‘just professional services’, there is no principled reason why institutions like the University Library could not face similar absorption tomorrow.
3. Operational Pressures Do Not Justify Constitutional Bundling
Temporary leadership pressures or administrative delays must not be used to leverage sweeping, permanent governance changes through the Regent House. Proponents argue that centralising power under the UAS is urgent for ‘efficiency’. Yet expanding central corporate control while stripping away independent technical oversight risks repeating past administrative missteps and reducing accountability. If the Council requires an immediate operational update for senior leadership, it should present that proposal cleanly, on its own merits, rather than demanding a blank cheque for central administrative expansion.
Voting non-placet is an active vote for open, democratic governance. It insists that major constitutional changes must be presented transparently, properly justified, and decided individually on their merits.
We urge members to vote non-placet, against both Graces.
Signed by the following 28 members of the Regent House:
H. Azerad
M. B. Beckles
M. Brett
J. Clark
R. G. Dillon
C. Ducati
A. J. Enright
R. C. Evans
R. A. Foley
M. R. Furness
P. J. Girling
D. K. Hart
R. S. Haynes
T. J. Hearn
J. R. Howlett
C. S. Kimbriel
J. P. King
P. F. Kornicki
M. H. Kramer
J. A. Langley
O. B. Linton
Y. Nobis
L. Pellegrini
S. A. Polonius-Teichmann
D. I. Redhouse
M. A. Ruehl
J. R. Y. Thurlow
Stephen Watts