Skip to main contentCambridge University Reporter

No 6839

Wednesday 14 October 2026

Vol clvii No 4

pp. 38–45

Report of Discussion: 6 October 2026

Tuesday, 6 October 2026

A Discussion was scheduled by videoconference with Deputy Vice‑Chancellor Professor Nicola Padfield, F, presiding and the deputy for the Director of Governance and Compliance, the Senior Proctor and the Junior Proctor as the attending officers.

Remarks were received as follows:

Remarks on the Reports and Financial Statements for the year ended 31 July 2025

(Reporter, 6833, 2025–26, p. 640).

Professor G. R. Evans (Emeritus Professor of Medieval Theology and Intellectual History):

Deputy Vice-Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor’s Annual Address to the University is published but does not have a place among Reports. Nevertheless in her Address on 1 October the Vice-Chancellor found opportunities to touch on matters which might need or give rise to Reports. What might those be?

She included resources in her list of ‘necessities’ and ‘opportunities’. ‘As University finances have become tighter, philanthropy has become ever-more important’, she suggested. She listed some ‘very big gifts’ received during the year and explained the uses to which they were being put. Fundraising successes were noted, including those of Colleges.

The inclusion of certain provision has led to controversy eventually requiring a Report and the establishment of the Judge Business School. Partnerships with external entities were also celebrated in the speech, noting ‘relationship with government around research and innovation infrastructure’ shifting ‘into partnership mode’.

In a respectful note on the University’s ‘democratic governance’ she added the need for it to operate ‘in keeping with modern demands’ for ‘transparency, legibility, timeliness and accountability’. But there is a wide range of possibilities of cooperation and collaboration, some of which may make one partner subordinate to or dependent on another. In seeking to make a particular provision the University may have to sacrifice its independence. The controversy over the future of the Vet School turned in part on such concerns.

So the celebration of the University’s achievements may perhaps benefit from a footnote here and there.


Dr W. J. Astle (MRC Biostatistics Unit):

Deputy Vice-Chancellor, I apologise that these remarks do not directly address the topic of the item. However, they concern a Grace intended to reconfigure the senior administrative offices of the University, including those senior officers responsible for finance, so there is a tangential connection.

At its meeting on 21 September, the Council agreed to publish a Notice endorsing a ruling by the Vice-Chancellor that a proposed amendment to Grace 2 of 29 July 2026, initiated by the Regent House, was incompatible with the main purpose of the Grace and therefore inadmissible. Notes of dissent are not attached to Council Notices, so I wish to express my opinion here that the Council should not have involved itself with the Vice-Chancellor’s ruling, whatever the merits of the original Grace, the proposed amendment, or the ruling itself.

In the absence of the Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor is, by custom, the Chair of the University.1 She is, therefore, the presiding officer of the governing body, the Regent House. Her power to rule amendments inadmissible derives from that status, not from her role as Chair of the Council.2 The Council is an administrative body inferior to the Regent House. It ought not to intervene in the procedures of the governing body, to which it is accountable.

The Charities Act 2011 may make the members of the Council the trustees of the University, but that does not make the Council the governing body. Nor does it give the Council a general power to overrule the Regent House, contrary to the Statutes and Ordinances. By law, charity trustees are obliged to comply with, and to exercise their powers within, the provisions of their charity’s governing documents.3

Several members of the Regent House have suggested to me that the incident deserves to be reviewed by the Commissary. I think that is true, but I also think that the delay caused by an application to the Commissary is unlikely to be in the best interests of the University, because of the urgent need to fill the senior administrative offices and because it is unlikely to lead to a different result. The concern is whether the ruling would have been made in the first place had the Council not given its endorsement.

Relatedly, the preamble to this year’s Proposed Roll of the Regent House (Reporter, 2026–27, Special No 1, p. 6), describes the Regent House as ‘the legislative and principal electoral body of the University’. According to web.archive.org, at some time between 13 November and 28 December 2025, the same phrase replaced the words ‘the governing body’ on the University governance webpage.4 The phrase has also been introduced to the booklet on the Regent House distributed to its new members.5 The Regent House is, by statute, the governing body of the University.6 It has executive as well as legislative powers.7 So, will the Council please ensure that it is accurately described in University publications?

Footnotes